Seriously funny satire

Supervising producer Ben Karlin (left), executive producer Madeleine Smithberg and host Jon Stewart confer on the set of The Daily Show, which won the George Foster Peabody prize for distinguished achievement and meritorious service (a prestigious journalism award usually reserved for actual news shows' in-depth coverage of a topic) for its treatment of the 2000 presidential campaign, "Indecision 2000."
(Photo by Al Levine)

Madeleine Smithberg '81, co-creator and executive producer of Comedy Central's
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart

Have you ever taken a stab at skewering your family by writing -- and performing -- satirical musical comedies about them? Figured out how to track down babies who swim, nuns who train miniature horses, or karate-chopping grandmothers for Italian TV? Or set up guest segments for Late Night with David Letterman that feature kid inventors, things that explode or eccentric people?

Madeleine Smithberg, executive producer and co-creator of Comedy Central's award-winning hit The Daily Show with Jon Stewart, has done it all. And more.

For those who haven't seen it, The Daily Show is a parody of an actual news show and is characterized by intelligent, hard-hitting satire that is equally irreverent to everything and everybody. What's unique about it is that it comments on news that hits the day the show is broadcast and it incorporates real news-source video clips. "Even the mechanics of it are more like news than they are like entertainment," said Smithberg. "The script is put together on an Associated Press computer program that's made for news broadcasts. The way our graphics are built, the way things are cut, the editing, the control room -- it's all very much like news."

In addition to the "looks real" factor, the show also boasts its own cadre of wacky national and international correspondents. "While we are most certainly a comedy show, we're anchored in pretending to be a news show," said Smithberg. "We mirror what the media are doing and we satirize the way the media cover things."

As with all good satire, there is a touch of seriousness behind the mask of the absurd. As Smithberg said, "It's given us entrée into some very touchy subjects." For example, the show aired a hilarious lambasting of the alarmist tone and stylistic changes in television reporting that took place in the aftermath of Sept. 11.

"After Sept. 11, we felt we didn't know what we were going to do," said Smithberg. "We felt as though we might never be able to get back on the horse, because it felt like news just wasn't funny. And then the tickers started running on the bottom of the screen on CNN, and anthrax happened and people went into 24-hour coverage of the anthrax scare without any actual information. And for us that was, 'Okay, thank you, guys! We're back in the game, because you're being ridiculous.' The media were trying to scare everybody, and it just seemed as though there was no restraint."

A talk show constitutes another element of the program, in which Jon Stewart interviews celebrity performers, authors and other guests. But this segment also has a news bent to it. "Since Sept. 11 we've tried to make the whole show more integrated, and we've been having a lot more serious news-related guests," said Smithberg.

Smithberg reads, watches and listens to myriad news sources throughout the day -- always with an eye to what's going to work for the show. She listens to NPR's Morning Edition as she gets up, moves onto CNN and Good Morning America while reading through The New York Times, then switches over to a news show on New York 1, which summarizes the top stories in five newspapers. She listens to another radio station in the car, reads through three more newspapers when she gets to work, and checks CNN online. The TV in her office is turned to CNN all day long.

Walk into the building and through the offices of The Daily Show, and you feel the high energy that the show's staff of 60 twentysomethings gives it. "I'm one of the oldest people in the building," said Smithberg, laughing. "I see the interns and think, oh my God, they look like children -- they have more in common with my 4-year-old son than they do with me. But that keeps you young." Smithberg appreciates not being part of corporate America, both for the relaxed work atmosphere -- everyone dresses very casually -- and for the free rein the show has in creating content. "On Comedy Central we can do almost anything we want," she said. "We're only held back by our own limitations; no one's really meddling in what we do. We don't have 18 layers of upper management putting creative notes in just for the sake of exerting their own professional power."

The bottom line, said Smithberg: "I love this hat. It's creative. It's collaborative. It's very exciting. There's also something immediately gratifying about doing daily television. Your day's work focuses on what's happened in the world that day, which makes it current and topical and relevant. That's very satisfying, especially when you get the idea it's actually having some sort of impact somewhere. It feels good. And obviously you can't live for outside recognition, but when it does come, it sure is better than not having it."

In addition to the Peabody Award, The Daily Show with Jon Stewart has won an Emmy for comedy writing and has been featured on 60 Minutes and in The New Yorker. In addition, Vanity Fair did a write-up of Stewart, and Smithberg has appeared on the News Hour, in Harper's Bazaar and in Elle.

The making of a comedy producer

Smithberg, who grew up on Mad magazine and was "blown away" when Saturday Night Live burst on the scene, landed her first foray into television thanks in large part to her fluency in Italian, something she acquired when she spent a semester abroad in Italy during her senior year as an art history major at Binghamton. Throughout the four years she worked for the New York office of an Italian national television station following her graduation, the Italians' fascination with American quirkiness prevailed. "They'd say, 'There are people in Texas who get in sleeping bags with snakes. Can you find them?'" recalled Smith-berg. And she'd track them down.

That's how Smithberg developed the "weird skill set," as she put it, that made her a prime candidate for David Letterman's show, which she described as "an unbelievable experience. It was just one of those situations where you're perfect for the job and that job is perfect for you." She had both the training and, as she put it, the "bizarre and specialized sensibility" needed for the human interest segment of Letterman's show that focused on the eccentric and the unusual. "I could read a newspaper and come up with four things to follow up on," said Smithberg.

For example, through the classified ads of the National Enquirer, Smithberg found a woman who cooked in her dishwasher. "We cooked in the dishwasher over the course of the show -- Dave introduced her at the beginning, and then at the end of the show we opened the dishwasher and out came the chicken with all the smoke. As it turned out, she was the live-in chef for Johnny Carson's lawyer. So my producer was thrilled, because we got it right out from under Carson's nose."

Now, Smithberg applies that same eye for the odd, the absurd and the jarring to The Daily Show. "If you watch the show on a regular basis, particularly the correspondents who do these field reports -- for better or for worse, my sensibility is all over it," Smithberg said. "It's that celebration of eccentricity taken to a new level; it also becomes a parody of the sort of misguided earnestness or self-servingness of investigative TV journalism."

TOP BACK TO FRONT